Are you stuck in the ‘free value trap’?


Last Wednesday, I emailed 13 free resources I’ve built over the past two years.

A client and friend, Ollie, messaged:

===

“Just seen your email. Love it. I’m concerned because my giveaways get great responses on social media but no buyers. I see influencers say they’re terrible for business. What do you think?”

===

For reference, Ollie is an injury specialist making decent money with his high ticket offer.

He’s in demand. For his giveaways to flop there must be something wrong. So I whipped out my Sherlock Holmes hat and asked what he last created.

His answer?

‘The 5 best shoulder exercises to get out of pain’.

And here, my dear Watson, lies the problem.

Ollie shows people how to get out of pain. If his free stuff does this too, why on earth would someone pay him for his advice?

It’s a common mistake. One that’s easy to overlook. One I’ve also fell victim too.

And one that’s easily avoided if you listen to the next 2 minutes of advice.

The purpose of free value is not to educate your audience.

It’s to excite them.

When you give away steps, blueprints, and frameworks, you’ll get many ‘thank yous’ in your inbox but zero dollars in your bank.

Sure, money ain’t the only metric of successful writing.

But it is an important one.

If you can’t get your audience to pay for your advice, you don’t know if they’re listening.

Yes, some will take your free stuff. But most will glance through then quickly forget you exist—it’s only when someone invests that they are truly invested.

But that's not to say free value doesn’t work.

It can be incredibly profitable… if you do it right.

Let me explain.

Your free assets should target the beliefs surrounding your offer so people want to buy. Your paid assets then get them the results.

For example, with Ollie’s program (which, by the way, I’ve taken, he’s 100x better than any physio I’ve seen), a great free asset would be:

The 5 Shoulder Injury Myths Your Physiotherapist Doesn’t Want You to Know.

Imagine how curious you’d be if you were chronically injured. Inside, he gives advice you haven’t heard before. He throws stones at the conventional path to prime his prospects for a different, more effective way to recover:

His.

If he then collects emails with this ‘Authority Asset,’ he knows every lead is problem-aware and intrigued by what he has to say. This is perfect for sending story-based emails—like this one I’m writing you.

And that, Reader, is how you turn free value into good money.

Hope this helps,

Kieran

P.S.

The free value trap applies to writing, too.

That’s why ‘Excite don’t Educate’ is Rule 3 of 10 of the Universal Rules of Magnetic Emails I give in my upcoming course.

It’s also one of the seven criteria for creating Authority Assets that build your business.

If you want a simple process for writing emails that lead to more relationships, reputation, and revenue, the launch is 1st September.

Join 2033 entrepreneurs on the waitlist by clicking the link below.

You’ve got me excited.

Kieran Drew

On a mission to become a better writer, thinker, and entrepreneur • Ex-dentist, now building an internet business (at ~$500k/year)

Read more from Kieran Drew

Last week, I sent an unfortunate message to my affiliates. I’d promised they could help launch Magnetic Emails. But I since changed my mind, explaining the launch would be private. No affiliates. No advertising. No selling on social media either. For reference, my last launch grossed 6 figures. Affiliate sales were 40% of the income. And I have 239,000 followers across social media platforms. So it’s a considerable chunk of business I’m throwing away. Why am I doing this? Because I was being...

Studies show 50% of businesses fail within 5 years. But I’d bet 95% of creator-first businesses will crash and burn. Consider this email a word of warning—a conversation I wish I had with myself three years ago. It begins with the truth: The online game isn’t as simple as people think. From an ‘outsiders’ perspective, every social media influencer is rolling in cash. Big brand deals, flashy cars, great holidays. This intrigues many people. So they dive into online business with their 4 Hour...

Three months ago, as I strolled along Leeds canal in the blistering UK heat (23 degrees), I listened to Tim Ferris interview Seth Godin. Ferris asked Godin how he’s kept so consistent with his popular daily blog, of which he’s posted 8,109 times. Godin replied with a point I loved: ”It’s not your job to say new things. It’s your job to say things that confirm your audience’s beliefs.” Most writers, myself included, think the secret to success is coming up with novel and unique ideas. But...